The short answer
- Job costing is tracking the actual costs of a construction job, by cost type, against the estimate while the work is still in progress.
- The figure that matters is the forecast final cost, meaning cost to date plus the estimated cost to complete, compared with the contract sum including agreed variations.
- Variations should be priced and agreed in writing before the work is done, or the cost lands on the job and the margin shrinks.
Job costing for builders means recording every cost on a job, sorted into labour, materials, plant, subcontractors and overheads, and comparing it with the estimate while the job is still running. The aim is to forecast the final margin early enough to act on it. A builder who only works out the profit when the final account is settled finds out about an overrun when it is too late to recover it.
What job costing is
A job cost is any cost that can be traced to a specific job. Job costing groups those costs under the same headings as the estimate, so each line can be compared four ways: estimated, spent to date, forecast to complete and forecast final cost. The difference between the contract sum and the forecast final cost is the forecast margin.
The habit matters more than the software. A weekly review of each live job, with the site manager’s view of what is left to do, catches most problems while there is still time to change the plan, talk to the client or price a variation.
The cost headings
| Heading | What goes in it | Where the figure comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Labour | Your own operatives’ time at their full cost rate | Timesheets or clocking in, by job |
| Materials | Everything bought for the job, less returns | Purchase orders, delivery notes, supplier invoices |
| Plant | Hired and owned plant, skips, scaffold, welfare | Hire invoices and internal plant rates |
| Subcontractors | Each package let to another firm | Subcontract orders, applications and payments |
| Overheads | A share of office, vehicles, insurance and management | An agreed allocation, often a percentage of value |
Labour at full cost
The most common error is to cost labour at the hourly wage. An operative’s real cost includes employer’s National Insurance, pension contributions, holiday pay, sick pay, travel and non-productive time. As an example, if an operative is paid £18.00 an hour and those extras add £5.40, the cost rate is £23.40 an hour. Estimating and job costing should both use the full rate, or every job will look more profitable than it is. A list of labour rates by trade and grade keeps this consistent.
Materials when committed
Record materials when they are ordered, without waiting for the supplier’s invoice a month later. A purchase order against the job shows the commitment at once, so the forecast reflects it. Match delivery notes to orders, and record returns and credits against the same job.
A worked example
A contractor is refurbishing a ground-floor office for a commercial client for a contract sum of £60,000, excluding VAT. The estimate breaks down as labour £18,000, materials £16,500, plant and skips £2,500, subcontractors £10,000 and overheads £4,800 (8% of the contract sum). The estimated cost is £51,800, leaving a margin of £8,200, or 13.7% of the contract sum.
Midway through the job, the site manager reviews each line, recording what has been spent and estimating what is left to do.
| Cost line | Estimate | Spent to date | Forecast to complete | Forecast final | Variance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Labour | £18,000 | £11,400 | £8,100 | £19,500 | −£1,500 |
| Materials | £16,500 | £9,800 | £6,200 | £16,000 | +£500 |
| Plant and skips | £2,500 | £1,700 | £900 | £2,600 | −£100 |
| Subcontractors | £10,000 | £4,200 | £6,300 | £10,500 | −£500 |
| Overheads | £4,800 | £2,640 | £2,160 | £4,800 | £0 |
| Total | £51,800 | £29,740 | £23,660 | £53,400 | −£1,600 |
The forecast final cost is £53,400, so the forecast margin is £60,000 − £53,400 = £6,600, or 11.0%. The job is still profitable, and £1,600 of margin has gone. The table shows where. Labour is £1,500 over because stripping out took longer than planned, and the electrical subcontractor has asked for £500 more for extra containment.
That is the moment to act. The site manager checks whether the extra strip-out came from conditions the contract puts at the client’s risk, and whether the extra containment was a design change. If either was, it should be priced and claimed as a variation.
Variations and how they affect margin
A variation is a change to the work in the contract, such as an addition, an omission or a change of specification, usually instructed by the client or their representative. Variations are where margin is most often lost, because work gets done on a verbal request and priced later, if at all.
Continuing the example, the client asks for an extra glazed partition. The contractor prices it at £2,400, made up of £1,800 cost and £600 margin, and the client confirms in writing before the work starts. The contract sum becomes £62,400 and the forecast final cost becomes £55,200. The forecast margin is £7,200, or 11.5%. If the same work had been done without agreement and never paid for, the margin would have fallen to £4,800, or 8.0% of the original sum.
- Get every instruction in writing, even if it is a text or email confirming a conversation.
- Price the variation and get agreement before doing the work, where the contract allows.
- Give each variation its own reference and cost code, so its cost is tracked separately.
- Include agreed variations in the next valuation instead of saving them for the final account.
Valuations and applications for payment
On most commercial jobs the contractor is paid in stages. An application for payment, or valuation, sets out the value of work done to date and claims the amount due. Job costing measures cost and valuations measure value, and the two should be read together.
In the example, at the midway review the contractor values the work done at £33,000. The contract has a retention of 5%, which the client holds back, usually releasing part at practical completion and the rest after the defects period. Previous applications have been paid at £22,000.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross value of work done to date | £33,000 |
| Less retention at 5% | −£1,650 |
| Net valuation | £31,350 |
| Less previously paid | −£22,000 |
| Due this application, excluding VAT | £9,350 |
Comparing value with cost shows whether the job is earning its keep as it goes. Here the value to date is £33,000 against costs of £29,740, a margin to date of £3,260, or 9.9%. That is below the forecast 11.0% for the whole job, which suggests either the valuation is light or costs have come early, and it deserves a second look. The rules on payment notices, CIS deductions and the VAT reverse charge are covered in CIS, reverse charge and payment notices.
Reviewing jobs weekly
- Post all timesheets, purchase orders and subcontract costs to the job by the end of each week.
- Ask the site manager for the cost to complete on each line, based on what is left to do.
- Compare the forecast final cost with the contract sum plus agreed variations.
- Investigate any line that has moved by more than an amount you set in advance.
- Decide what to do, whether that is changing the method, pricing a variation, talking to the client or accepting the loss knowingly.
- Record the forecast margin so you can see how it moves from week to week.
Spreadsheet or software
A spreadsheet works for one or two jobs if someone keeps it up to date. It breaks down when costs come from several people, when the estimate lives in a different file, and when variations, valuations and invoices are tracked somewhere else again. Software that keeps the estimate, purchase orders, timesheets, variations and invoices in one record per job removes the re-keying that makes figures go stale.
Estimark is built around one record per job, from the estimate through scheduling to invoicing, with a price book, labour rates and reports. For choosing a system, see how to choose estimating and quoting software.
Questions people ask
What is a good margin for a building job?
There is no single right margin for a building job, because it depends on the type of work, the risk, the client and how overheads are recovered. What matters is knowing the margin in the estimate and tracking whether the job is achieving it. Compare the forecast final margin with the estimated margin on every job.
Should overheads be included in job costs?
Including a share of overheads in job costs shows whether each job contributes enough to run the business. A common method is to allocate overheads as a percentage of each job’s value, based on annual overheads divided by annual turnover. Some builders track direct costs and overheads separately and report both margins.
What is the difference between a valuation and an invoice?
A valuation, or application for payment, sets out the value of work done to date and the amount claimed. The invoice is the document used for VAT and accounting. On many construction contracts the invoice is issued once the amount due has been agreed or notified.
How often should I review job costs?
Review job costs weekly on any live job of meaningful size. Weekly reviews catch overruns while there is still time to act. Monthly reviews often find problems after the money has already been spent.