The short answer
- Subscription e-commerce sells physical products on a repeating schedule, such as subscribe-and-save replenishment, curated boxes or memberships, with the customer charged automatically each cycle.
- Some subscribers leave only because a card payment failed, so build automatic retries, card updating and dunning emails before launch.
- UK consumer law is moving towards subscriptions that are as easy to leave as to join, so design cancellation that takes a few steps online, with clear reminders before renewals.
Subscription e-commerce is the sale of physical products on a repeating schedule, where the customer signs up once and is then charged and sent an order automatically each cycle. The common models are subscribe-and-save replenishment, curated boxes and paid memberships. Whether a subscription business keeps its customers depends on what happens after the first order: billing cycles, failed payments, skipping and pausing, and cancellation that is as easy as signing up.
The three subscription models
| Model | Example | What drives the software |
|---|---|---|
| Replenishment, or subscribe and save | Coffee, pet food or contact lenses every 2, 4 or 6 weeks | Flexible frequency, a repeat-order discount, easy changes to quantity and date |
| Curated box | A monthly box whose contents the business chooses | A fixed cut-off date, contents planning and forecasting how many boxes to pack |
| Membership | Paid access to member prices, free delivery or early releases | Entitlements checked at checkout, plus renewal and expiry |
Many shops mix them. A coffee roaster might sell a replenishment plan for a customer’s favourite blend alongside a monthly discovery box. Each model needs the same billing foundations and different screens on top.
Billing cycles and cut-off dates
Every subscription needs a billing date, a fulfilment date and a rule linking the two. For replenishment, customers are usually charged a few days before dispatch, so a failed payment can be fixed before the parcel goes out. For a curated box, everyone is billed on or before a common cut-off date, after which the contents and quantities are fixed. Decide these points before you build:
- whether cycles run from each customer’s sign-up date or align to one date for everyone;
- whether a customer who joins after the cut-off gets this month’s box or next month’s;
- how price changes reach existing subscribers, with notice before the next charge;
- whether a change of plan takes effect now, with a pro-rata adjustment, or at the next renewal.
Charges after the first are merchant-initiated transactions. Authenticate the first payment under Strong Customer Authentication and record the customer’s agreement to future charges, and later charges can then usually go through without the customer being present. Direct Debit is the other common route in the UK, with the Direct Debit Guarantee protecting customers. On Shopify, subscriptions run through subscription apps built on its subscription APIs; on a custom build, billing usually runs on your payment provider’s subscription features. We compare the two routes in Shopify or a custom build.
Failed payments and dunning
Dunning is the process of recovering a failed subscription payment by retrying the charge, asking the customer to update their card and, if nothing works, pausing the subscription. Cards fail for ordinary reasons, such as expiry, a replacement card after a fraud alert, low funds on the day or a bank’s risk check. A customer whose card failed did not choose to leave, so recovering them deserves real effort. A sound sequence:
- Retry automatically on a schedule, for example after one, three and seven days. Many payment providers offer retries timed by their own models.
- Use card updater services through your provider, which can refresh expired or replaced card details from the card networks.
- Email the customer straight after the first failure, with a secure one-click link to update their card.
- Send one or two reminders, each saying what happens next and when.
- Hold the order until payment succeeds, and tell the customer it is waiting.
- After the last retry, pause the subscription and keep the customer’s details, so they can restart with one click.
The mechanics are the same as recurring billing in software products, which we cover in billing for SaaS.
Pausing and skipping
Pausing and skipping are useful retention tools, because a customer with too much coffee in the cupboard otherwise has only one button to press, and it says cancel. Let customers do all of these without contacting support:
- skip the next delivery;
- pause for a set number of cycles, with the restart date shown;
- move the next delivery earlier or later;
- change frequency or quantity.
Every skip and pause also tells you something. A customer who skips three times in a row is probably oversupplied and could be offered a longer gap between deliveries before they decide to cancel.
Cancellation that is easy
Making cancellation hard keeps a few subscribers for a short while and creates complaints, chargebacks and legal risk. UK law is moving firmly in the other direction. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 includes a new regime for subscription contracts. As passed, it requires clear information before sign-up, reminders before renewals and before a free or discounted trial ends, and a straightforward way for customers to leave. The subscription provisions are being brought into force separately from the rest of the Act, with detail set by regulations and guidance, so check the commencement date and the final rules before you design your flows.
Existing rules already apply. Under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, a customer who buys goods online usually has 14 days to cancel, and for regular deliveries of goods that period runs from delivery of the first goods. Perishable goods are among the exceptions. Rules on unfair terms and misleading practices also apply to subscription traps. In practice, design cancellation the way you design sign-up:
- a cancel option in the account, reachable in a few taps;
- at most one retention offer, such as a pause or a discount, with “Cancel anyway” just as visible;
- an immediate confirmation email stating the last charge and the last delivery;
- renewal and trial-end reminders sent before the charge, each with a link to cancel.
Forecasting stock from subscriptions
Subscriptions give you advance notice of demand, which an ordinary shop does not have. For a curated box, start with active subscriptions and subtract the skips and cancellations you expect before cut-off, based on your own recent history. With 1,200 active subscriptions, and an average over the last three cycles of 90 skips and 40 cancellations before cut-off, plan for 1,200 − 90 − 40 = 1,070 boxes. Add the new sign-ups you expect before cut-off, and a small buffer for damaged parcels and replacements.
For replenishment, add up the next delivery dates for each product over the coming weeks, then adjust each product by its own skip rate. Share that forecast with purchasing every week, because a supplier’s lead time is often longer than one subscription cycle.
The metrics that matter
- Monthly recurring revenue (MRR): the value of active subscriptions, converted to a monthly amount.
- Churn: the share of subscribers who leave each month, split into voluntary, where they cancelled, and involuntary, where a payment failed.
- Recovery rate: the share of failed payments that dunning recovers.
- Skip and pause rates: early warnings of churn.
- Gross margin per order: after product, packing and delivery.
- Customer lifetime value: gross margin per month divided by monthly churn.
Take a £25 box with a 40% gross margin, which earns £10 a month. At 5% monthly churn, the average subscriber stays 1 ÷ 0.05 = 20 months, so lifetime margin is about £200. If winning a subscriber costs more than that, the business loses money on each one, however fast it grows. Our article on SaaS metrics covers the same measures in software.
Questions people ask
What is dunning in subscription e-commerce?
Dunning is the process of recovering a failed subscription payment. It combines automatic retries, card updater services and emails asking the customer to update their payment details. If payment still fails, the subscription is paused so the customer can restart easily.
How easy does subscription cancellation have to be in the UK?
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 contains a subscription regime that requires a straightforward way to leave, along with reminders before renewals and trial ends. Its provisions are commencing separately from the rest of the Act, so check the current position. Existing consumer law already treats subscription traps as a risk.
How do you calculate subscription churn?
Monthly churn is the number of subscribers who left during the month divided by the number at the start of the month. With 1,000 subscribers at the start and 50 cancellations, churn is 50 ÷ 1,000 = 5%. Track voluntary and involuntary churn separately, because they have different fixes.
Do subscription payments need Strong Customer Authentication every time?
Usually not. The first payment should be authenticated, and later charges that the merchant starts under the customer’s agreement are generally treated as merchant-initiated transactions. The card issuer can still ask for authentication, so the software needs a way to bring the customer back to approve a payment.