Build log/Working with us

Fixed price vs time and materials: choosing a software contract model

Fixed price puts the risk of overruns on the supplier and suits well-defined work. Time and materials puts it on the client and suits products that will change. A retainer buys ongoing capacity.

The short answer

  • A fixed-price contract sets one price for an agreed scope, so the supplier carries the risk if the work takes longer, and any change to the scope goes through a change request.
  • Time and materials bills for the time actually spent at agreed day or hourly rates, so the client carries the risk of overruns and keeps the freedom to change direction.
  • A retainer pays for an agreed amount of capacity each month and suits ongoing improvements, support and maintenance once a product is live.

Fixed price, time and materials, and retainers are the three common ways to pay for software work, and the main difference between them is who carries the risk when work takes longer than expected. A fixed-price contract sets one price for a defined scope. Time and materials charges for the hours or days actually worked. A retainer buys a set amount of a team’s time each month.

How fixed price works

The supplier estimates the work, adds a contingency for the risk it is taking on, and quotes one price for an agreed scope. Payments are usually tied to milestones, such as signing the contract, delivering a prototype and acceptance of the finished release. If the work takes longer, the supplier absorbs the cost. If it goes faster, the supplier keeps the difference.

Take an illustrative day rate of £500, chosen to make the sums easy. The supplier estimates 40 days, which is £20,000, and adds 25% contingency for a fixed price of £25,000. If the work takes 32 days, the client pays £25,000. If it takes 55 days, worth £27,500, the client still pays £25,000 and the supplier absorbs the extra £2,500 of its own time.

Fixed price only works when the scope is written precisely enough that both sides would agree whether a given request is in or out. That needs a specification with acceptance criteria, which is one reason fixed-price builds usually follow a discovery phase.

How time and materials works

Under time and materials, the client pays for the time worked at agreed rates, usually reported weekly or at the end of each sprint, plus any agreed costs such as licences. The supplier gives an estimate, often as a range, and the final cost follows the actual work.

In the same example, 32 days would cost £16,000 and 55 days would cost £27,500. The client gains if the work is quicker and pays more if it is slower. In exchange, the client can change priorities at any point without renegotiating, which suits a new product where you learn as you build. A budget cap, sometimes called capped time and materials, limits the exposure. When spending reaches the cap, work pauses for a decision.

To keep time and materials under control, ask for working software at the end of each sprint, a simple chart of work completed against budget spent, and a regular review where you reorder what comes next. Seeing real progress every week or two is the best early warning of an overrun.

How a retainer works

A retainer pays a fixed monthly fee for an agreed amount of capacity, such as a number of days of development, support and hosting management. It suits a live product that needs steady improvement, security updates and help when something goes wrong. Agree what happens to unused days, how urgent issues are handled, and how much notice either side needs to change the amount. Software maintenance costs explains what a live product needs each month.

How each model shares risk

Fixed priceTime and materialsRetainer
Who carries overrun riskSupplierClientShared, within the monthly capacity
Cost certainty for the clientHigh, for the agreed scopeLow to medium, unless cappedHigh, per month
Freedom to change scopeLow, through change requestsHighHigh, within the capacity
Contingency in the priceBuilt inNone, you pay for actual timeNone
Best forWell-defined, bounded workNew products and evolving scopeLive products
Main riskDisputes over what is in scopeBudget driftPaying for capacity you don’t use

Fixed price can cost more than time and materials for the same work, because the supplier prices in contingency. It can also cost less, if the work turns out harder than anyone expected. The trade is certainty against flexibility.

When each model fits

  • Fixed price fits a discovery phase, a bounded integration, a marketing site, or a build whose scope has been fully specified.
  • Time and materials fits the first version of a product, where real users will change what you build, and any work with big unknowns, such as integrating with an undocumented system.
  • A retainer fits a product after launch, when the work is a steady flow of small improvements and fixes.

Many projects combine them. A common pattern is a fixed-price discovery phase, then time and materials for the build in fixed-length sprints with a budget cap, then a retainer once the product is live.

How change requests work

A change request is the formal way to alter an agreed scope. In a fixed-price contract it is the only way, and a clear process prevents most disputes.

  1. The client describes the change in writing.
  2. The supplier assesses its effect on cost, timeline and other features, and replies in writing.
  3. The supplier offers options, such as adding cost, swapping out another feature of similar size, or moving the change to a later phase.
  4. The client approves one option in writing before work starts.
  5. The scope document, plan and price are updated, so everyone works from the same version.

For example, partway through a fixed-price build the client asks for invoices to be sent to their accounting package. The supplier estimates 4 days, or £2,000 at the example rate, and offers to drop a reporting screen of similar size instead. The client chooses the swap, and the price stays at £25,000.

Under time and materials, changes are handled by reordering the backlog. They still cost money, so the same habit of writing them down and agreeing their effect on the budget helps.

What to put in the contract, whichever model you choose

The pricing model is one clause among several that matter just as much.

  • Who owns the code, designs and documents, and when ownership passes to you (who owns the code).
  • Acceptance criteria, and how long the client has to test each delivery.
  • Payment terms and what triggers each invoice.
  • A warranty period for fixing defects found after acceptance.
  • Termination terms, and handover of the repository, credentials and documentation if you part ways.

Take legal advice on the contract itself, especially on intellectual property and liability.

Comparing ways to pay for a build? See how we price projects.

Questions people ask

Is fixed price cheaper than time and materials?

Not necessarily. A fixed price includes contingency for the supplier’s risk, so if the work goes to plan it usually costs more than the same work on time and materials. If the work turns out much harder than expected, fixed price protects the client. In effect, you are paying for certainty.

Can a fixed-price project change scope?

Yes, through a change request. The supplier assesses the effect of the change on cost and timeline, offers options such as swapping out another feature, and the client approves one in writing. Without that process, changes lead to disputes about what the fixed price covered.

What is capped time and materials?

Capped time and materials bills for the actual time worked, like normal time and materials, and sets a maximum spend for a phase or sprint. When the cap is reached, work pauses until the client decides whether to increase the budget, reduce the scope or stop. It limits risk without fixing the scope.

How is a retainer different from time and materials?

Both charge for time. A retainer commits to a fixed amount of capacity each month for a set term, which gives the client a predictable cost and the supplier a reason to keep the same people on the product. Time and materials charges for whatever time is used, with no fixed monthly amount.

Which contract model suits a startup MVP?

We’d usually suggest a fixed-price discovery phase followed by capped time and materials. Discovery fixes the cost of deciding what to build, and capped time and materials lets you change priorities as you learn while keeping spending under control.

Written by Flavoureak

We build and run Estimark, CurioKids and CalcStack, and we build web and mobile software for other businesses. Start a project.